Thursday, November 19, 2009

Hard of Hearing

Voters send a message, but the White House ignores it.

Elections matter. They are sometimes governed by voters' passion; they sometimes change the course the country is following (as in 2008); and sometimes, like earlier this month, they fire warning shots across the bow of our ship of state.
On Nov. 3, the voters in just about every election told our governments they were moving in the wrong direction, and that the course must be changed.
Barack Obama carried Virginia last year, but his party lost substantially in this fall's gubernatorial election. Republican Bob McDonnell carried nine of the 11 Virginia congressional districts, including three that Democrat Congressional candidates won last year. In those three districts, Mr. McDonnell got 62%, 61% and 55% of the vote.
Over in New Jersey, a big-time Democrat state where incumbent governor Jon Corzine outspent his opponent 3 to 1, Republican Chris Christie won, 49% to 45%. Mr. Obama carried New Jersey a year ago by a margin of more than 15%, so the voter swing was 20 points from Democrat to Republican.
In Pennsylvania, Mr. Obama in 2008 carried the four counties of suburban Philadelphia with 57% of the vote. This year the Republican Supreme Court candidate won them 55% to 45%, and six of the seven statewide winners were Republicans.
Even more important to future election results may have been the youth and senior citizen voting. In New Jersey, the 2008 youth vote was 17% of the total, and went for Mr. Obama 67% to 31%. But in 2009 the youth vote was just 9% of the total and went for Mr. Corzine only 57% to 36%. In Virginia the youth vote made up 21% of the total in 2008 and went for Obama by a 21% margin. It was only 10% of the vote this year, and it went Republican by a 10% margin.
Senior citizens' voting patterns were even more interesting. In New Jersey they were 15% of the vote in 2008, with a 6% majority for John McCain; this year, they were 19% of the vote and went for Mr. Christie by 15%. In Virginia, they were 11% of the voters in 2008 and went for Mr. McCain by a 7% majority; this year, they were 18% of the voters and McDonnell won them by 20%.
So while the youth vote dropped and shifted pro-Republican, the senior citizen vote increased and went even more Republican.
To put all this in pollster perspective, Gallup reported that Democrats led the generic ballot question--"Which party do you support in local congressional elections?"--by 15 points last December and six points in July. Last week Republicans had a four-point lead.

***

You may recall February's Newsweek cover story "We Are All Socialists Now," forecasting that the "America of 2009 is moving towards a modern European state," and as it does it "will become even more French." So there will be "more government taxing and spending" and "more government intrusion in the economy will almost surely limit growth."
We have already seen an explosion in spending, and higher taxes will be with us on Jan. 1, 2011, when the Bush tax cuts expire. If Congress does nothing, the tax rate on capital gains will rise from 15% to 20%. The House health-care bill contains a 5.4% surtax, brainchild of Rep. Charlie Rangel, that would take the rate up to 25.4% for higher-income taxpayers. The two increases together, as The Wall Street Journal pointed out, amounts to a 69% hike.
The Joint Tax Committee reports that one-third of the project $460 billion revenue from the Ragel tax would be paid by small-business owners, who are employers and job creators. Says the New York Times: "It is fitting that they pay a heavy share of the cost of health care reform." And since none of these taxes are indexed for inflation, 10 years from now this tax bite will apply to people and small businesses with incomes equivalent to perhaps $335,000 today.
Facing the prospect of higher taxes, government-managed and -controlled health care, and the huge costs of the pending global-warming bills, people at home and now people in the Congress are beginning to have second thoughts. According to Rasmussen's recent polls, 42% of Americans strongly oppose the health care bill while only 25% strongly support it, and according to Gallup only 29% of people would advise their congressmen to vote for it--substantially down from last month's 40%.
Members of Congress of course pay close attention to their constituents. Of the 80 Democratic House members whose districts were carried by either George W. Bush or Mr. McCain, 9 voted against the "stimulus" bill, 21 voted against a budget resolution for doubling the national debt in four years, 36 voted against "cap and trade," and 36 voted against the health-care bill.
What we don't know is if this trend will continue as the Senate votes on health care (if it can get past a filibuster), and both houses vote on any conference bill, or whether many Senate Democrats will want nothing to do with a climate bill or, most important, will attempt to slow the massive growth of annual spending. But if the Democrats ignore the public's growing skepticism, the Republicans will do very well in the 2010 elections.

***

Most surprising is that the Obama administration sees no important message in this month's election and has made no change in its legislative strategy. If the Republicans make real progress in the elections next November, what does the administration do then?

 

Wednesday, November 18, 2009

Dissection of Palin's 'Going Rogue' begins

Sarah Palin's book, "Going Rogue," came out Tuesday, a best-selling compilation of anecdotes, political prescriptions and score settling.
The former Alaska governor's 413-page book caused a media sensation, with exhaustive coverage and friends and foes scrutinizing every word.
Palin writes about her Wasilla upbringing, her marriage and children, and how her early aspirations to be a television sports reporter turned into a life of politics. She describes her trajectory from Wasilla city politics to governor; from the vice presidential campaign trail to her resignation this summer, when she decided it was time to "pass the ball."
Palin, who has not given interviews to Alaska news media since leaving office, describes her decision to step down, a move that shocked even some of Palin's closest supporters.
In the wake of the presidential campaign, her administration was besieged by public records requests and ridiculous ethics complaints designed to bankrupt her, she writes. Her approval ratings in Alaska plunged from almost 90 percent to 56 percent amid a "one-sided public discourse" over the ethics claims, she writes.
"Slowly and steadily, my record, my administration's efforts, and my family's reputation were shot to hell," Palin writes.
Clarity came in a telephone call from Iraq with her enlisted son, Track, she writes. Her son urged her not to let the criticism get to her, she writes, that she shouldn't take a "dishonorable discharge," and should only leave office if it was to move up to something more worthy. Palin described asking if it was worthy to protect her family, to fight for Alaska and the nation, and to break the "bureaucratic shackles" paralyzing the state.
"I'm not a quitter, Track ... I'm going to fight."
Palin writes that the "sheer volume of paperwork and legally required responses brought the business of governing the State of Alaska to a grinding halt. Eventually it overwhelmed us - and was obviously meant to."
Andrew Halcro, a former Republican state legislator and frequent Palin critic, said she could have pushed to change how Alaska deals with ethics complaints, and it's "asinine" to say Alaska governing came to a standstill because of them.
"I mean, really, was the commissioner of education working on complaints? Did you have (resources commissioner) Tom Irwin in there instead of working on the gas line, digging through FOIA requests?" said Halcro, who lost to Palin for governor in 2006 and is preparing a campaign for Congress against Rep. Don Young.
Halcro said what he's seen so far of Palin's book is an exercise in blaming others. "She's accepted very little responsibility for pretty much anything that's gone wrong in her life," Halcro said.
Palin's lawyer, Tom Van Flein, said Tuesday that those who claim that Palin is using the book to blame others are the same people who have unfairly criticized her and failed to take responsibility themselves.
"All Sarah Palin is doing is pointing out what really happened, and there are a lot of people who are uncomfortable with the truth of what occurred," he said.
Palin described Halcro in the book as a "wealthy, effete young chap who had taken over his father's local Avis Rent A Car, and he starred in his own car commercials."
Some of Palin's sharpest criticism is aimed at top aides on Sen. John McCain's presidential campaign. She writes that the campaign muzzled her and failed to stop anonymous staffers from making vicious claims about her to the press.
The book is "total fiction," the Arizona senator's former campaign manager, Steve Schmidt, told CNN. Palin paints him as a screaming, back-biting political operative. Throughout the book, Palin doesn't name some people she disparages, including many from Alaska. One is Anne Kilkenny of Wasilla, who wrote a long e-mail warning of Palin's small-town leadership, ultimately forwarded around the country. Kilkenny is referred to in the book as both "the town crank" and a "Birkenstock-and-granola Berkeley grad who wore her gray hair long and flowing."
Palin's former legislative director, John Bitney, also doesn't get named, although Palin criticized him for, among other things, turning "out to be a Blackberry games addict who couldn't seem to keep the lunch off his tie." Bitney, who was a high school classmate of Palin and worked on her campaign for governor, said he was hurt by it. "On the Blackberry, it takes one to know one, as far as Blackberry etiquette, and I guess I don't have her clothing budget to be as GQ as she wanted."
Much of the national media coverage has focused on Palin's criticism of the McCain campaign staffers, as well as her recounting that the McCain campaign forced her to pay $50,000 in legal bills for the cost of vetting her as a vice presidential candidate. The campaign's general counsel told the Associated Press that was untrue, and McCain told a Capitol Hill publication, The Hill, the expenses were instead related to the "Troopergate" investigation.
McCain told The Hill that he nevertheless enjoyed the signed book that Palin gave him and wishes her well. "I hope she sells lots of them," he said.
Fact-checking and debates over the book's worth raged on Tuesday. Palin makes much in her book of her admiration for President Ronald Reagan. His "sense of national purpose resonated with me," Palin wrote of Reagan, who took office when she was in high school. "I liked him, and I liked the fact that he was never afraid to call it as he saw it."
The fact-checking Web site Politifact.com on Tuesday disputed some of Palin's claims, including that Reagan led the nation out of a recession that is worse than the one it currently faces.
The New York Times book review described "Going Rogue" as "part cagey spin, part earnest autobiography, part payback hit job." National Republican strategist Mary Matalin said in an interview she was saddened by Palin's fight with McCain campaign strategists, but said Palin is good at defending herself. Matalin described the book as eloquently laying out conservative principles.
"She's a unique voice, and she's a clear voice for common-sense conservatism," Matalin said.
Palin will now embark on a nationwide book tour, starting today in Grand Rapids, Mich., and continuing by bus to other small cities across the country. Writing in the final paragraph of the epilogue, she says she has often been asked, "Where are you going next?"
"Good question! I'll be heading home to Alaska, of course. Back to that kitchen table. We'll discuss the day's news and the next stop. I always tell my kids that God doesn't drive parked cars, so we'll talk about getting on the next road and gearing up for hard work to travel down it to reach new goals."

Another Look at Obama's Job Approval

If you are looking for a good snapshot of where President Obama's job approval is right now, you cannot do better than the RealClearPolitics average. It's intuitive, straightforward, and indispensable.
Another way to look at Obama's job approval is to examine the trend line for each pollster. This can offer a way to control for their "house effects." The following chart does that by looking at the monthly average of eight major media pollsters (Fox, CBS, CNN, Ipsos, Pew, NBC, ABC, and AP).
Obama Job Approval.jpg
A few observations are in order:
1. By separating the pollsters from one another, we can see the various house effects. For instance, CBS and ABC are the most favorable polls to Obama while Fox and NBC tend to be the least. AP and CNN are the "bounciest." Some months, they are above the average. Other months, they are below.
2. Obama's job approval slid precipitously from July through August. This coincides with the heating up of the health care debate. This trajectory is consistent across all eight pollsters.
3. The President rebounded a bit from his August/September lows, but he is now at or near his lowest point in all of the polls except the (bouncy) AP poll, which had him much lower in September than the other polls. This chart makes that clear:
Obama High and Low.jpg
4. The polls generally find Obama's overall job approval higher than his approval on various issues. For instance, these are the results of the latest ABC News/WaPo poll:
ABC News:WaPo Issues.jpg
One can't help but wonder if a legislative success on the health care package will result in a further decline in the President's job approval rating.
5. What will be interesting to watch next year is whether the President's job approval slides further as the campaign begins in earnest. Will the Republican argument against Obama and the Democrats - once it hits the airwaves - damage the President's standing further? It is possible. Ronald Reagan and Bill Clinton both suffered about 8-point declines in their job approval ratings from January to November of their first midterm years. [Obama is about where both Presidents were at this point in their terms, a little behind Reagan and a bit ahead of Clinton.] George W. Bush's net approval dropped 36 points in 2002; of course, it was very high after 9/11. Also regarding Bush 43, when the Democratic campaign against him heated up in early 2004, his net job approval slid 13 points from the first of the year to the beginning of the summer.
Will the Republican argument against Obama push some voters who disapprove of Obama on specific issues into overall disapproval? Will it push some of those marginal approvers into disapprove/don't know?

Tuesday, November 17, 2009

GOP Dark Horses for 2012

By Tom Bevan & Mike Memoli
Three years before the 2008 election, Barack Obama was a freshman Senator from Illinois who had wowed the crowd with his keynote speech at the 2004 Democratic National Convention. He was touted as a rising star in the Democratic party, but not seriously considered as a legitimate presidential candidate for the 2008 race. Likewise, in November 2005 Mike Huckabee was serving his ninth year as Governor of Arkansas and was on no one's radar screen as a serious presidential contender. Twenty-six months later Huckabee stormed the field, won the Iowa caucuses, and went on to finish second to the eventual nominee, John McCain.
This time around, Huckabee now sits atop the heap of speculation about possible GOP candidates for 2012, along with other familiar faces including former Vice Presidential nominee Sarah Palin, Mitt Romney, and Newt Gingrich. There is a new face in the mix as well: Minnesota Governor Tim Pawlenty is actively pursuing the rubber-chicken circuit and giving off every indication that he will throw his hat in the ring.




Receive news alerts














[+] More
But there are a handful of other potential Republican presidential candidates who are getting little, if any, attention. It's possible a number of these Republicans who are not currently part of the conversation will decide to make the race and could emerge as serious contenders for the nomination. So who are the GOP dark horses for 2012? Click here to see the list.

Monday, November 16, 2009

Hoffman 'unconcedes' in N.Y.-23 House race


By Jordan Fabian - 11/16/09 06:34 PM ET
Conservative Party candidate Doug Hoffman has "unconceded" in New York's special House election after reports that the vote margin between him and Rep. Bill Owens (D) has narrowed.
Hoffman conceded the race on Election Night after learning he trailed Owens by 5,335 votes. But the Syracuse Post-Standard reported last week that the margin had shrunk to 3,026 votes after recanvassing.
Hoffman appeared on conservative commenatator Glenn Beck's radio show this afternoon. Beck asked the him if he would "unconcede.""Yes, if I knew this information at the election night, I would not have conceded," Hoffman said. Beck asked him again if he was "uncondeding" and Hoffman replied "If that’s possible, yes."
Officials in the upstate New York district are still counting over 10,000 absentee ballots, which also had Republican nominee Dede Scozzafava's name on them. Scozzafava dropped out of the race three days before election day citing poor fundraising and polling returns. She then backed Owens.
Owens was sworn into Congress on Nov. 6, just before Democrats voted on the healthcare reform bill on Saturday. Should Hoffman come away with more votes, a highly unlikely possibility, Owens would have to be removed from office, according to the House Clerk.
Hoffman would have to take over 65 percent of the absentee ballots in order to eclipse Owens. In the interview, Hoffman admitted his victory would be a "long shot."

So much for the power of incumbency

Gov. Jon Corzine (D) failed to win reelection in New Jersey . . .
Gov. Jon Corzine (D) failed to win reelection in New Jersey . . . (Mel Evans/associated Press)
 
 
Washington Post Staff Writer
Monday, November 16, 2009


Amid the spin spewing from the parties over what this month's elections in New Jersey, Virginia and New York meant, there is one indisputable lesson learned: Voters don't like incumbents these days.
New Jersey Gov. Jon Corzine (D) was thrown out by voters, and New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg (I) was nearly defeated despite outspending his opponent by 20 to 1.
Although the candidacy of Conservative Party nominee Doug Hoffman fell short in the special election in Upstate New York's 23rd Congressional District, his rapid rise was based mainly on anti-Washington, throw-the-bums-out messaging.
Virginia's governor's race did not include an incumbent, but voters roundly rejected the party of President Obama and outgoing officeholder Tim Kaine, the chairman of the Democratic National Committee.
In Pew Research Center's polling, just over half of Americans said they would like to see their members of Congress reelected next fall. Only 34 percent said they want most incumbents to be reelected in the midterms.
Pew describes those numbers as among the most negative in two decades of collecting data. They approach levels found in the run-ups to the 1994 and 2006 midterms -- elections in which there were significant seat changes in the House and Senate. In October 2006, 55 percent said they wanted to see their lawmakers reelected and 37 percent favored the reelection of most members of Congress; in October 1994, 49 percent favored the reelection of their own lawmakers and 29 percent backed reelection of Capitol Hill incumbents in general.
Even more troubling for incumbents is that independent voters are more down on their elected officials than partisans of either stripe. Only a quarter of independents want to see congressional incumbents reelected next year, while 42 percent support their own lawmakers in the midterms.
ad_icon
What's clear from this and other national polling as well as a variety of state data is that there is a widespread belief that politicians are not acting in the best interests of those they represent. This sentiment isn't terribly new, but the depth of these anti-incumbent feelings -- particularly among political independents -- makes it newsworthy.
While it's likely that any sustained sentiment of this sort will hurt Democrats more than Republicans, this sort of political environment is decidedly unpredictable and could lead to surprising defeats for presumed safe incumbents -- of both parties -- next November.
D for defeat?

Two Quinnipiac University polls released late last week in Ohio and Connecticut provided sobering news for Senate Democrats.
In Connecticut, Sen. Christopher Dodd (D), whose numbers experienced a resurgence over the summer, trailed former congressman Rob Simmons (R) by double digits.
Even against such virtual unknowns as former World Wrestling Entertainment chief executive Linda McMahon, state Sen. Sam Caliguri and former ambassador Tom Foley, Dodd is in a statistical dead heat.
Need more evidence? Just 40 percent approve of the job Dodd is doing in Congress, and just 39 percent say he deserves reelection. Not good. At all.
The data in Ohio was less daunting for Democrats but still dispiriting. Republican former congressman Rob Portman polled 39 percent support compared with 36 percent for Lt. Gov. Lee Fisher (D), a significant reversal from a September survey, in which the Democrat led by double digits.
Since neither Portman nor Fisher is particularly well known, the turnaround is attributable almost entirely to a general decline in the Democratic brand, as shown by the majorities who disapprove of how Obama is handling the economy and health care.
Gov. Ted Strickland is also feeling the effects, having slipped into a dead heat with former congressman John Kasich (R).
Connecticut and Ohio are among the five states most likely to switch parties next year. Here are all five:
5. Ohio (Republican-controlled): Portman is the class of this field -- an able, attractive candidate with star power. But, he has direct ties to the unpopular economic and trade policies of the Bush administration (he served as U.S. trade representative and as head of the Office of Management and Budget) that Democrats are planning to exploit. Fisher is vulnerable to a primary challenge from Secretary of State Jennifer Brunner, but repeated fundraising failures suggest she doesn't have the tools to put together a candidacy.
4. New Hampshire (R): The recently announced candidacies of Republican businessmen Bill Binnie and Ovide Lamontagne complicate former state attorney general Kelly Ayotte's march to the nomination. Binnie is likely to position himself to Ayotte's left, while Lamontagne is sure to cast himself as the only real conservative in the field. Rep. Paul Hodes, meanwhile, has a free run at the Democratic nod.
3. Nevada (Democratic-controlled): The current anti-incumbent climate has to worry Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, who has built a career on his insider smarts. Reid's early television ads echo the sort of spots Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) ran in 2008; they are transactional -- designed to show voters what Reid gets for the state and what him not being in the Senate would mean. Reid's greatest advantage, however, may be the quality (or lack thereof) of his Republican opponents.
2. Delaware (D): State Attorney General Beau Biden (D) continues to play coy about whether he will run for his father's old seat and, if so, when he'll announce those plans. Assuming Biden gets in soon, it will set up a terrific race against Rep. Mike Castle (R), whose long record of electoral successes in the First State make him a formidable opponent.
1. Connecticut (D): When Dodd's numbers tanked this spring, his allies insisted that there was still plenty of time for him to set things right with voters. And, over the intervening months, he seemed to get his feet under him -- and his poll numbers improved as well. That's why the Quinnipiac numbers are so troubling for Dodd -- they not only show a significant regression for the incumbent, but they also come less than a year before the vote. Expect increased pressure from party leaders for Dodd to step aside.
Countdown

One day: "Going Rogue," former Alaska governor Sarah Palin's memoir of the 2008 presidential campaign, is officially released.
20 days: Palin stops in Sioux City, Iowa, to sign copies of her book. Fix rule: Politicians never go to Iowa by accident.

Dede Scozzafava Is No GOP Moderate

She is a donkey in an elephant costume.

By Deroy Murdock

Re-canvassed votes in upstate New York’s 23rd Congressional District foreshadow the second coming of third-party candidate Doug Hoffman. As Mark Weiner of the Syracuse Post-Standard reported Thursday morning, Conservative nominee Hoffman’s 5,335-vote deficit behind Democrat Bill Owens has shrunk to just 3,026 after Election Night tabulation errors were corrected. Some 10,200 absentee ballots remain uncounted. State Board of Elections spokesman John Conklin told Weiner, “All ballots will be counted, and if the result changes, Owens will have to be removed.”

However this develops, before Election Day 2009 vanishes into the rear-view mirror, one big myth demands correction, lest it harden into “fact.” Dede Scozzafava is no moderate Republican. The GOP state assemblywoman who abandoned this special election boasts a solid liberal record of votes and activism far left of the GOP’s center, or even its wobbly port flank — home of Maine senators Susan Collins and Olympia Snowe.


Nonetheless, the GOP’s detractors are showcasing Scozzafava as “proof” that reasonable centrists are unwelcome in today’s intolerant, extreme, far-right Republican party.

The Washington Post’s Jason Horowitz called the six-term legislator “a little-known state assemblywoman with moderate Republican views and a mouthful of a surname.” Horowitz’s November 10 piece was sub-headlined: “It’s a Grand Old Purging as moderate’s ouster spotlight’s Republican dysfunction.”

As CBS News’s Steve Chaggaris remarked: “Conservative Republicans will undoubtedly claim victory in sidelining the moderate GOPer, Scozzafava.”

UrbanDictionary.com now defines “Scozzafaved” as being “Purged of moderation, e.g., within a Congressional district.”

Scozzafava is no upstate version of Long Island’s Peter King (2008 American Conservative Union rating: 50) nor Florida’s Lincoln Diaz-Balart (52), truly centrist congressional Republicans who somehow go astray without offending the party’s beliefs or enflaming its base. Conversely, Scozzafava is a donkey in an elephant costume. Consider just a few lowlights from her previous record and recent campaign:

Scozzafava earned a feeble 15 out of 100 on the New York Conservative party’s latest legislative report card. Sheldon Silver, an ultraliberal Manhattan trial lawyer and State Assembly Democratic leader, earned a 10. Conservative party chairman Mike Long observed that in the state house, “46 Democrats have voting records more conservative than the Republican pick for Congress!”

Scozzafava voted not once, not twice, but 190 times to raise or extend taxes. Few issues are more sacred to the GOP faithful than tax limitation. There is nothing moderate about violating this core party tenet — not rarely, but nearly 200 times.

Indeed, Scozzafava’s tax votes are so bad that the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee  attacked her on them.

“Albany politician Dede Scozzafava voted to raise or extend taxes on New Yorkers over 190 times,” declared a September 22 DCCC press release, denouncing “increases on sales taxes to wireless surcharges.”



As columnist Michelle Malkin recalls, Scozzafava voted in Albany for Democratic budgets, approved a $180 million state-level bank bailout, and backed President Obama’s $787 billion stimulus package.

Scozzafava favors “card check” legislation that would kill secret ballots in union-organizing elections. She also accepted campaign cash from the Longshoremen’s, Electrical Workers’, and Service Employees’ unions, as well as the National Education Association, the notorious teacher’s union that just screams “NO!” to nearly every school-choice initiative.

“I was first on the Planned Parenthood board when I returned to the North Country,” Scozzafava said last year as she accepted the Family Planning Advocates’ Margaret Sanger Award for pro-abortion activism. It’s bad enough for a Republican to be pro-abortion. But must she be an award-winning pro-abortion Republican?


Scozzafava was endorsed by the leftist, ACORN-associated Working Families Party and ran on its ballot line with 2008’s Obama-Biden ticket and 2004’s Kerry-Edwards team.

Scozzafava was endorsed by Markos Moulitsas, editor of The Daily Kos, arguably the Left’s most influential political website. Beneath the headline “NY 23: The most liberal candidate leads (and it’s not the Dem),” Moulitsas wrote: “So it’s official, I’m rooting for the Republican to win.”

Citing polling numbers that plunged after the district’s mainly GOP voters recoiled at her record, Scozzafava suddenly fled the race on Halloween, just three days before the election. Most nominal Republicans would have mirrored the Republican National Committee and endorsed Conservative Hoffman, or at least stayed neutral. Instead, Scozzafava did something truly un-Republican: She embraced Democrat Bill Owens. With Scozzafava’s backing, and amid all this tumult, Owens edged Hoffman 49 percent to 45 on November 3, with Scozzafava scoring 5 percent.

If elected, Hoffman would have rebuffed Nancy Pelosi’s Obamacare bill on November 7. That might have persuaded Rep. Ahn Cao (R., La.) to reverse his lone GOP “yes” vote and join his conference in unanimously rejecting Pelosi’s 1,990-page behemoth. Seeing 100 percent Republican opposition might have inspired another Democrat to spurn this legislation. Obamacare then would have failed by exactly one vote, and this entire sick mess would have flatlined. Thus, Dede Scozzafava is as plausibly responsible as anyone for keeping Obamacare alive.

GOP voters and activists at least grudgingly can accept moderate Republicans who sometimes violate Reaganite principles, especially in states like New York that are not quite Texas or Utah. But henceforth, GOP leaders must understand that picking Scozzafavian candidates is a recipe for revulsion among party stalwarts. If GOP elders prefer to see teardrops rather than confetti fall on election night, they should nominate more Democrats like Dede Scozzafava.

— Deroy Murdock is a New York-based columnist with the Scripps Howard News Service and a media fellow with the Hoover Institution.